Back to Feed
r/ClaudeAI
by LegalPresentation888
Analyzed
Claude can't generate images, but it can edit them perfectly with Computer Use
13 points
12 comments
94% upvoted
View on Reddit
Content
I asked three AI assistants to remove the background from my image (a simple "cut out" task).
\- ChatGPT (with DALL-E): X Drew the transparency checkerboard pattern as actual background
\- Gemini (with Nano Banana): X Same issue - included the checkerboard in the final image
\- Claude (no image generation): O Perfect transparent PNG using Computer Use
The irony? The AI without image generation capabilities did it best.
Here's what Claude did autonomously with Computer Use:
1. Installed necessary Python libraries (rembg, OpenCV, PIL)
2. Tried THREE different approaches:
\- Basic threshold method
\- Color-based detection (targeting the orange infinity symbol)
\- GrabCut algorithm (AI-powered precision removal)
3. Generated three versions for me to compare
4. Delivered actual transparent PNGs
https://preview.redd.it/9rwwhnikhabg1.png?width=1008&format=png&auto=webp&s=051437673b7c1723c12b2324d358bb5c79d1d874
(The conversation was in Korean, but you can see Claude autonomously writing Python scripts, running them, and generating the output files - no manual coding required on my end!)
Why this matters:
This perfectly demonstrates the power of Computer Use:
\- Claude can't generate images
\- But it CAN use the same tools a developer would use
\- It wrote Python code, installed packages, ran algorithms, and delivered production-ready files
\- The "limitation" became irrelevant because it solved the problem differently
Sometimes having the right tools beats having the built-in feature.
Disclaimer: My prompts to ChatGPT and Gemini might not have been optimal - perhaps there's a better way to ask them for background removal. But that's also part of the point: Claude's Computer Use approach was intuitive and just... worked. No special prompting required, no workarounds needed.
Comments
No comments fetched yet
Comments are fetched when you run cortex fetch with comment fetching enabled